# I compared Google ratings to AI recommendations for 88 Orlando dentists. Review count mattered more than the stars.

*2026-11-09* · *Original Research*

> 88 Orlando-area dental practices, 318 AI answers, four AI platforms. Practices rated 4.8 were named in 41% of answers, practices rated 5.0 in 31% and practices rated 4.7 or lower in 27%. Practices with 1,000 or more reviews were named in 56%.

Past 4.8 stars, a higher Google rating did not get Orlando dental practices named more often by AI. Review count did. I checked 88 Orlando-area practices against 318 answers from ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini and Perplexity in November 2026.

Practices rated 4.8 were named in 41% of the answers for their area, practices rated 5.0 in 31%, and practices rated 4.7 or lower in 27%. Practices with 1,000 or more Google reviews were named in 56%, and practices with fewer than 200 in 16%.

## What did I compare?

On November 4 and 5, I asked ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini and Perplexity for a dentist in 11 Orlando-area neighborhoods and cities, from Dr. Phillips to Sanford. Each tool got three patient questions per area: who is the best dentist, what are the top rated practices, and can you recommend a good one. Claude, Gemini and Perplexity answered each question three times. ChatGPT answered each once, in 7 of the 11 areas.

That produced 318 answers. I then took the 88 practices in those areas with a known Google rating and review count, and counted how many answers in each practice's own area named it.

## Do higher-rated Orlando dental practices get named more often?

Only up to 4.8. Orlando practices rated 4.8 were named in 41% of their area's AI answers, those rated 4.9 in 37%, those rated 5.0 in 31%, and those rated 4.7 or lower in 27%.

| Google rating | Practices | Average share of their area's AI answers that named them |
| --- | --- | --- |
| 5.0 | 20 | 31% |
| 4.9 | 33 | 37% |
| 4.8 | 12 | 41% |
| 4.7 or lower | 23 | 27% |

Head to head, there were 254 pairs of practices in the same area with different ratings. AI named the higher-rated practice more often in 132 of those pairs and the lower-rated one in 107. Fifteen were ties. Higher-rated practices won 55% of the pairs that had a winner, a small edge.

## How often does a lower-rated practice out-name a 4.9 or 5.0?

Often: of the 53 Orlando-area practices rated 4.9 or 5.0, 35 had a lower-rated practice in the same area that AI named more often. For 22 of them, that practice was rated 4.7 or lower.

In Dr. Phillips, AI named a practice rated 4.2 in 25 of the area's 30 answers, and all four tools named it.

> For 35 of the 53 Orlando-area practices rated 4.9 or 5.0, AI named a lower-rated practice in the same area more often.

In 7 of the 11 areas, the practice AI named most was not the highest-rated practice in that area.

## What does predict which Orlando dentists AI names?

Review count tracked much more closely than the rating.

| Google reviews | Practices | Average share of their area's AI answers that named them |
| --- | --- | --- |
| 1,000 or more | 15 | 56% |
| 500 to 999 | 19 | 37% |
| 200 to 499 | 41 | 29% |
| Under 200 | 13 | 16% |

Of the 15 practices with 1,000 or more reviews, 13 were named at least once and 10 were named by every tool asked in their area.

The practice's name may also matter. In 4 of the 11 areas, the most-named practice has the area in its name, the way Sanford Dental Excellence was named in all 30 Sanford answers. A patient asks for a dentist in a place, and a practice named after that place is an easy match. I have not tested this beyond these 11 areas, so treat it as an observation.

## I have a 4.9. Am I covered?

A 4.9 rating alone does not tell you. Of the 53 Orlando-area practices rated 4.9 or 5.0, 9 were never named in their own area, and 13 were named in fewer than one answer in ten. Seventeen were named by one tool or none.

For those 9 practices, every answer in their area named a different practice. Nothing in a Google Business Profile dashboard shows that.

For the share of Orlando practices each AI platform named, see the [Orlando dental research](/research/markets/dental/orlando) page. It counts practices a different way from this post, so the totals differ.

The only way to know is to ask the tools. The [free scan](/check) asks ChatGPT, Claude, Perplexity, Gemini and Google AI Overviews for a dentist in your area, then shows which ones name your practice and which ones name someone else. It takes about a minute.

**See which AI tools name your practice.** → [See Who ChatGPT Recommends](https://getlocalvitals.com/check)

## What are the limits of this Orlando data?

This comparison covers the 88 Orlando-area dental practices I had Google ratings for. It does not cover every practice in the metro.

It is one metro and one week. Ratings and review counts were current as of November 3, 2026.

ChatGPT was asked once per question, in 7 of the 11 areas. The other three tools were asked three times per question in all 11.

It shows what moved together. It does not prove that more reviews cause more recommendations. A practice with 1,000 reviews is usually older and listed in more places, and those things may matter more than the count.

Corrected November 16, 2026. The first version of this post said 81 practices and 323 answers, and that practices rated 4.6 or lower were named in 46% of answers. Recounted from the saved scan and rating list, the figures are 88 practices, 318 answers and 30%. The head-to-head result also changed: higher-rated practices won slightly more pairs, not fewer. The opening now compares the rating groups in the table (4.8 at 41%, 4.7 or lower at 27%) instead of a 4.6-or-lower group the table did not show. The finding about review count holds.

---
Source: https://getlocalvitals.com/blog/google-rating-vs-ai-recommendations-orlando-dentists
Published by Local Vitals · https://getlocalvitals.com