Florida Plumber AI Visibility Study
AI named a plumber in 99.5% of 600 answers. Sixteen plumbers showed up on all four AI tools. 73% showed up on only one.
Last updated: November 2026
600
AI Answers Analyzed
4
AI Tools Tested
10
Florida Metros
978
Plumbers Named
Study scope
600
AI queries tested
Across 5 plumbing specialties: general plumber, emergency plumber, drain cleaning, water heater repair, sewer line
10
Florida metro areas
Miami, Tampa, Orlando, Jacksonville, Ft. Lauderdale, West Palm Beach, Naples, Sarasota, Tallahassee, St. Pete
4
AI platforms tested
Claude, ChatGPT, Gemini, Perplexity
12
Queries per city/specialty
3 query types per specialty: best in city, who to call, find a reliable provider
Key findings
Executive summary from the full report. No email required.
- AI names plumbers in almost every answer. 597 of 600 answers named at least one plumber (99.5%).
- 73% of plumbers showed up on one AI tool only. We counted 978 distinct plumbers. 266 were named by two or more tools.
- Sixteen plumbers were named by every tool. All four tools named Roto-Rooter Plumbing & Water Cleanup, Raider Rooter, Flow Pros Plumbing, Next Plumbing and 12 more.
- The tools that search the web often name the same plumbers. Asked the same question, Claude and Perplexity named at least one plumber in common 69.8% of the time. ChatGPT and Claude did 55.4% of the time.
- Gemini is the outlier. Gemini answered from its training data, without a live search. It shared a plumber with ChatGPT on 19.6% of questions and with Perplexity on 18.8%.
- Angi is the site AI names most for plumbers. Angi was named in 29.7% of answers, Yelp in 22.5% and BBB in 13.2%. Google in any form was named in 25.8%.
- National brands are 15% of the names. 459 of 3,068 business mentions were a franchise or national chain. The rest were local companies.
Platform comparison
Share of each AI tool's answers that named at least one business.
150 of 150 answers named a business
150 of 150 answers named a business
149 of 150 answers named a business
148 of 150 answers named a business
How many AI tools named each business
72.8% of plumbers were named by just one AI tool.
Named by every tool
Roto-Rooter Plumbing & Water Cleanup, Raider Rooter, Flow Pros Plumbing, Next Plumbing, Olin Plumbing, Pro-Tec Plumbing & Air, Aztec Plumbing & Drains, Bill The Plumber, David Gray Plumbing, Douglas Orr Plumbing, Drain Genie Plumbing Services, Frank Gay Services, Metro Rooter, Modern Plumbing Industries, Inc, Mr. Rooter Plumbing of Tallahassee, Wimpy's Plumbing & Air.
Do the tools agree?
Share of questions where both tools named at least one business in common.
- Claude + PerplexityBoth searched the web.69.8%
- ChatGPT + ClaudeBoth searched the web.55.4%
- ChatGPT + PerplexityBoth searched the web.46.9%
- Claude + GeminiGemini answered from training data, without a live search.25.3%
- ChatGPT + GeminiGemini answered from training data, without a live search.19.6%
- Gemini + PerplexityGemini answered from training data, without a live search.18.8%
Sites AI named
Share of answers that named each site. Compare ten trades
- Angi29.7%
- Google25.8%
- Yelp22.5%
- BBB13.2%
- Thumbtack6.2%
- HomeAdvisor5.5%
The bottom line
AI tools name plumbers in almost every answer, and the tools that search the web often name the same ones. Even so, 73% of the plumbers named showed up on one tool only. Start by finding out which tools name you.
Cite this research
Valero, A. (November 2026). Florida Plumber AI Visibility Study. Local Vitals. getlocalvitals.com/research/florida-plumber-ai-visibility
This research is published under CC BY-NC 4.0. You may cite and reference this data with attribution.
Get the full report
The whole study as an 8-page PDF: results by AI tool, city and service, the businesses every tool named, how often the tools agree, and the sites AI named.
Free. Just takes an email.
About this study
600 questions were asked across Gemini, Claude (with web search), Perplexity and ChatGPT (GPT-4o with search) in April 2026, covering 10 Florida metro areas and 5 services. Gemini was asked through its API without a live search, so its answers come from training data. Business names were read from each answer by software and matched across tools after formatting was removed. In a spot check, about 19 in 20 extracted names were real businesses. Answers were stored cut at 2,000 characters, so names and sites past that point come from fields saved when the questions were asked. The second question in this study read "who is taking new patients", a wording error. No sponsored placements or paid SEO tools were used.
Questions about the data or methodology: hello@getlocalvitals.com