Skip to main content
← All posts
Original ResearchPublished · Updated

We Ran 600 AI Queries for Local Service Businesses. Only 23 Made It Onto All Four Platforms.

When a homeowner asks AI for a plumber, HVAC company, electrician, roofer or landscaper, AI names a specific local business in 87% of answers, and 80% of the businesses it names are recommended by only one platform. That is from 600 questions Local Vitals asked ChatGPT, Perplexity, Google AI Overviews and Gemini across 10 U.S. metros in April 2026, and it is for service business owners outside Florida who want to know how AI picks.

In Nashville, two businesses in the whole metro were named by all four platforms. Across the study, 23 of 1,571 were.

How did Local Vitals run the national study?

We selected ten metros ranging from large (Dallas-Fort Worth, Nashville, Portland) to mid-size (Tucson, Omaha, Columbus). Five trades: plumbing, HVAC, electrical, roofing, and landscaping. Three query types per trade, designed to mirror natural homeowner language. Fifteen queries per city, times four AI platforms, times ten cities. Six hundred data points.

We categorized every response by whether the AI named specific local businesses, gave generic advice without names, recommended only national franchises, or redirected to a directory like Yelp. In some cities, Google AI Overviews didn’t trigger at all, meaning the query produced no AI-generated answer.

How often does AI recommend specific local businesses?

Across all 600 queries, 87% returned specific local business names. That number was even higher on some platforms: Perplexity and ChatGPT both named local businesses on nearly every query. The fear that AI only gives generic advice is wrong. When someone asks for a plumber, AI usually answers with names.

Does every AI platform recommend the same businesses?

Different platforms name different businesses. Of 1,571 businesses named across the study, 80% were recommended by only one AI platform, and 23 (1.5%) appeared on all four.

Ask ChatGPT for a roofer and ask Perplexity the same question, and you will usually get different names. Showing up on one platform tells you little about the other three.

How consistent are Google AI Overviews across cities?

In Portland, Nashville and six other cities, Google AI Overviews appeared on every question and named local businesses each time. In Raleigh-Durham and Tucson, they appeared on none of the 15 questions.

FindingMetro
Google AI Overviews on every questionPortland, Nashville and six other cities
Google AI Overviews on no questionsRaleigh-Durham, Tucson
Most businesses on all four platformsOmaha, 8
No businesses on all four platformsDallas-Fort Worth, Raleigh-Durham
Highest franchise share of answersNashville, 42%
Lowest franchise share of answersPortland, 15%

Which AI platforms agree on who to recommend?

Google AI Overviews and Gemini named overlapping businesses 61% of the time. Perplexity and ChatGPT did 37% of the time. The average across all platform pairs was below 10%.

Smaller metros agreed more. Omaha had eight businesses on all four platforms. Dallas-Fort Worth and Raleigh-Durham had none.

Do national franchises dominate AI recommendations?

Franchise brands appeared in 15% to 42% of responses depending on the city. Roto-Rooter was the most frequently cited franchise in the study. But in every single metro, independent local businesses made up the overwhelming majority of AI recommendations.

Nashville had the highest franchise penetration at 42%. Portland had the lowest at 15%. Local operators are not being crowded out by national brands in AI search. Not yet.

Which sources do AI platforms cite most?

The BBB was the most-named third-party site in seven of ten cities, with up to 24 mentions per metro. Yelp led on the West Coast, and Angi appeared in every city. ChatGPT named BBB data more than the other platforms did.

The sites changed by trade. For plumbers, the BBB was named three times as often as any other site. For roofers the BBB also led, and for landscapers Yelp did.

What should service business owners do about AI visibility?

The data from this study shows something most people haven’t grasped yet: there is no single AI search to optimize for. There are four, and they barely agree on who to recommend.

In the written report, the 23 businesses on all four platforms had a few things in common: reviews on several sites, BBB accreditation, matching business details across directories, and a page for each service on their websites. That is an observation from 23 businesses, not a tested cause.

AI already recommends local service businesses: 1,571 of them in this study. The question is whether it recommends yours.

The free Local Vitals scan checks your business across ChatGPT, Gemini, Claude, Perplexity and Google AI Overviews in about 60 seconds.

What are the limits of this study?

This was the first Local Vitals study, run in April 2026 on four platforms (Claude was added in later studies). It counted answers in 10 metros and 5 trades, 15 questions per city per platform. The Florida studies that followed use a larger sample per trade, and their method pages give more detail. The full national dataset is available at hello@getlocalvitals.com.

Find out what AI says about your business.

See Who ChatGPT Recommends