3,468 AI queries, 5 industries, 1 pattern: most businesses show up on only one AI platform
When a Florida customer asks AI for a dentist, plumber, HVAC contractor, roofer or eye doctor, AI names a specific local business in 96.9% to 99.5% of answers, and most businesses it names show up on only one platform. That is from 3,468 questions Local Vitals asked ChatGPT, Perplexity, Gemini, Claude and Google AI Overviews across 10 Florida metros in April 2026, and it is for owners in those five trades.
The studies for each trade: dentists, plumbers, HVAC contractors, roofers and eye doctors. Each question was a service plus a Florida city, like “who’s the best plumber in Tampa.”
We've since extended the same methodology to other Florida service categories. The full per-industry data is also available for electricians, landscapers, and pest control.
Is AI actually recommending local businesses by name?
AI platforms name a specific local business in almost every answer. Here are the five trades side by side:
| Trade | Answers that named a business | Named on only one platform | Google AI Overview appeared |
|---|---|---|---|
| Plumbers | 99.5% | 72.8% | not measured |
| HVAC | 99.5% | 78.5% | 12% |
| Dentists | 99.3% | 79.5% | 45% |
| Roofers | 99.0% | 77.3% | 14% |
| Eye doctors | 96.9% | 85.5% | 4% |
If you are a dentist or plumber in Florida, AI is handing out recommendations right now. The question is whether those recommendations include your business or only your competitors.
Do ChatGPT, Gemini, Claude, and Perplexity recommend the same businesses?
Sometimes. Claude and Perplexity shared at least one business on 63% to 72% of questions in every industry. ChatGPT and Gemini shared one on 5% to 20%.
The platforms that search the web overlap the most. In plumbing, Claude and Perplexity named at least one plumber in common on 70% of questions. ChatGPT and Claude did on 55%.
Gemini was the outlier in every industry. We asked it through its API without a live search, so it answered from training data. It shared a business with ChatGPT on 20% of eye care questions, 20% of plumbing questions, 14% of roofing questions, 8% of dental questions, and 5% of HVAC questions.
Claude and Perplexity were the closest pair of chat platforms in every industry: 72% in HVAC, 70% in plumbing, 66% in dental and roofing, and 63% in eye care.
How many businesses appear on more than one AI platform?
Here's the number that matters most: across every industry, between 73% and 86% of the businesses AI named appeared on only one platform.
Eye care was the highest at 85.5%. Dental, 79.5%. HVAC, 78.5%. Roofing, 77.3%. Plumbing, 72.8%.
A small group showed up on every platform we could compare: 16 plumbers, 15 HVAC companies, 10 dental practices, 3 eye care practices, and 1 roofer. That is 45 businesses out of 6,230 named.
That means if a customer uses ChatGPT and you only show up on Gemini, they will never see your name. They will see someone else's.
How often does Google AI Overviews trigger for local service searches?
Google AI Overviews show up far less often than the chat platforms answer.
For dental it was 45%, roofing 14%, HVAC 12% and eye care 4%.
For an HVAC company, that means Google showed regular results with no AI answer on 88 of every 100 searches. Most AI recommendations for these trades happen on ChatGPT, Gemini, Claude and Perplexity.
Do national franchises dominate AI recommendations?
National brands do not dominate AI results. In four of the five industries, independent businesses got more than 92% of AI mentions.
Plumbing was the one exception, where franchises and national chains like Roto-Rooter and Mr. Rooter got 15% of mentions. In dental, chains like Aspen Dental got 3.7%. In eye care, national chains got 1.6%.
Independent businesses already have the edge here. But only if AI can find them.
Which directories does AI pull from for each trade?
Each trade leans on different review sites and directories.
For plumbers, Angi is the site AI named most, followed by Google in some form, then Yelp and the BBB. For HVAC contractors, Angi, the BBB, and Yelp were nearly tied. For roofers, the BBB comes first and was named in about half of all answers. For eye doctors, Healthgrades was named in 37% of answers and Zocdoc in 28%.
Your Google Business Profile helps with Google. For ChatGPT, Perplexity and Claude, the review sites and directories for your trade matter as much. The Local Vitals report on The sites AI names when customers ask for a local pro (November 2026) breaks this down for 10 trades.
What should local service businesses do about AI visibility?
AI is already sending customers to specific businesses. In at least 96.9% of answers, it names someone. The free scan shows whether that someone is you.
Showing up on one platform is not enough. Between 73% and 86% of the businesses AI named appear on only one. Your customers use different AI platforms. If you only show up on Gemini, ChatGPT is naming someone else.
The right directories are your biggest lever. Complete profiles, accurate information, and strong reviews on the directories that matter for your trade are what AI uses to decide who gets recommended.
How can you check your own AI visibility right now?
Start with the directories that matter for your trade. Plumbers and HVAC contractors: Angi, Yelp, and BBB. Roofers: BBB first. Eye doctors: Healthgrades and Zocdoc. Dentists: Yelp, Healthgrades, and Zocdoc. Make sure your profile is complete, your phone number and address are correct, and your reviews are recent.
Then search for yourself on ChatGPT and Perplexity. Type "best [your trade] in [your city]." See what comes back. If your business is not in the answer, that is what your customers are seeing too.
Check your visibility across all five AI platforms at once.
See Who ChatGPT RecommendsNext step: run the free Local Vitals scan, which takes about 60 seconds.