Skip to main content
← All posts
How It WorksPublished · Updated

What AI search is, and how it differs from Google

AI search is when a customer asks ChatGPT, Perplexity, Gemini, Claude or Google AI Overviews a question like “who’s a good plumber near me” and gets a short answer naming a few businesses, instead of a list of links. This explainer is for local business owners who know how Google works and want to know what is different.

The answers name names. In the Local Vitals Florida Plumber AI Visibility Study (April 2026, 10 Florida metros), AI named a specific plumber in 99.5% of answers. Local Vitals has asked AI more than 5,000 questions about local businesses across its studies.

What are ChatGPT, Perplexity, and Google AI Overviews actually doing?

AI search platforms like ChatGPT, Perplexity, Gemini, Claude and Google AI Overviews give a direct answer, such as “here are three good plumbers in your area,” in place of ten links to scroll through.

For the person asking, it’s faster and easier. For the business being recommended, it’s incredibly valuable. For the business that isn’t being recommended, it’s a problem they don’t even know they have.

And these platforms do recommend businesses by name. In our Florida plumber study, AI named a specific plumber in 99.5% of answers. In eye care, 96.9%. These aren’t vague suggestions. They’re names and recommendations.

How does AI decide which businesses to recommend?

Google ranks websites based on signals it checks in real time: your reviews, your location, your profile activity, your website content. Update your Google Business Profile today and it can affect your ranking this week.

AI platforms work differently from each other. ChatGPT, Perplexity and Claude searched the web before answering in our studies. Gemini, tested through its API, answered from its training data with no live search, which is why it agrees with the others least.

The sites AI reads depend on your trade. From the Local Vitals report on The sites AI names when customers ask for a local pro (November 2026, 4,409 answers):

TradeSite AI named mostNext
PlumbersAngi, 36%Yelp 27%, BBB 15%
RoofersBBB, 55%Angi 32%, Yelp 29%
LandscapersAngi, 36%Yelp 28%, Houzz 17%
Eye doctorsHealthgrades, 40%Zocdoc 29%, Yelp 14%

A business that appears on the sites its trade leans on, with the same name, address, phone and services everywhere, gives AI more to work with than one that appears in one or two places.

Does every AI platform recommend the same businesses?

Every AI platform recommends a different set of businesses, and the overlap is small.

In the Florida plumber study, AI named 978 different plumbers across four platforms, and 72.8% of them were named by only one. Sixteen appeared on all four. Ask ChatGPT and Gemini the same question in the same city, and four times out of five they name no plumber in common.

In the Florida Eye Doctor AI Visibility Study (April 2026), the spread was wider: 85.5% of practices appeared on only one platform.

What about Google’s AI Overviews?

Google AI Overviews are the AI summaries that sometimes appear at the top of Google’s results. They sit on Google’s own results page, so your Google Business Profile matters there.

But here’s the problem: Google AI Overviews are inconsistent from trade to trade. In our Florida studies, they appeared on 69% of pest control searches, 45% of dental searches, 12% of HVAC searches, and 4% of eye care searches. For pediatric eye doctors, the rate was 0%.

ChatGPT and Gemini, meanwhile, answered nearly every question. For most local trades, AI recommendations happen more often in the chat platforms than in Google’s Overview.

What determines whether AI recommends your business?

Four things separate the businesses AI names from the ones it skips, in our studies and audits.

First, presence on the sites your trade uses. A business with 50 Google reviews and nothing elsewhere gives AI less to go on than one with reviews on Angi, Yelp or Healthgrades as well.

Second, matching details. If your business is “Joe’s Plumbing LLC” on Google, “Joe’s Plumbing” on Yelp and “Joseph’s Plumbing” on the BBB, AI may treat those as three different businesses.

Third, mentions on sites that aren’t yours, like a local news story or a supplier’s partner page.

Fourth, website pages that match how people ask. In a Local Vitals gap analysis for a Tampa managed print company, it was named in 2 of 32 question-and-platform combinations. The competitor named six times had a page titled “Managed Print Services in Tampa Bay: What It Costs and How to Choose a Provider.” See the full Tampa analysis.

What should local businesses do about AI search right now?

Your Google ranking still matters. People still search on Google. That’s not going away.

Google is no longer the only place people look, and the businesses AI names are the ones it can find the most consistent information about.

The good news: the steps that improve AI visibility (more directory listings, consistent business data, earning mentions, building website content) also help your Google ranking. They’re not competing priorities. But if you’re only focused on Google reviews and nothing else, you’re building on one platform while an entire new channel of customer discovery is passing you by.

How long does it take to show up in AI search?

Listing and profile fixes show on those sites within days. AI answers may take weeks to change, and some do not change at all. Gemini, which answers from training data, is slowest. Check the same questions 30 days after your fixes, then again at 90.

The free Local Vitals scan checks your business across all five AI platforms in about 60 seconds.

Find out what AI says about your business.

See Who ChatGPT Recommends