85.5% of the Florida Eye Doctors AI Named Showed Up on Only One AI Platform
When a Florida patient asks AI for an eye doctor, AI names a specific local practice in 96.9% of answers, and 85.5% of the practices it names show up on only one platform. That is from the Local Vitals Florida Eye Doctor AI Visibility Study (April 2026, 627 questions across 10 Florida metros), and it is for eye care practices deciding where to focus.
The study covered general eye doctors, optometrists, ophthalmologists, LASIK surgeons and pediatric eye doctors on ChatGPT, Perplexity, Gemini, Claude and Google AI Overviews.
Does AI actually recommend eye doctors by name?
When an AI platform answered, it named a specific local eye care practice 96.9% of the time (468 of 483 answers). A patient in Miami who asks ChatGPT for a good eye doctor almost always gets a name.
How many eye doctors appear on more than one AI platform?
We identified 1,037 unique eye care practices across the platforms. Of those, 85.5% appeared on only one platform.
Three eye care practices appeared on every platform we could compare: Bascom Palmer Eye Institute, Center for Excellence in Eye Care, and Florida Eye Clinic. Another 37 appeared on three.
A patient asking ChatGPT and a patient asking Gemini the same question got at least one practice in common only 20% of the time. Google's AI Overviews answered too few eye care searches to compare.
How often does Google AI Overviews recommend eye doctors?
Google’s AI Overview barely appears for eye care.
Google's AI Overviews, the AI-generated answers that appear at the top of search results, triggered on only 4% of eye care queries. For comparison, they appeared on 45% of dental searches and 69% of pest control searches in our other Florida studies.
| Platform | Named a practice |
|---|---|
| Claude | 100% (28 of 28 answers) |
| Gemini | 99.3% |
| Perplexity | 96.7% |
| ChatGPT | 94.0% |
| Google AIO | Appeared on 4% of searches |
Gemini named a practice in 149 of 150 answers. Google barely answers at all. For pediatric eye doctors specifically, the trigger rate was 0% across all ten Florida cities. Google's AI never once generated a recommendation.
For eye care, the platforms recommending practices to patients are ChatGPT, Gemini, Claude and Perplexity far more than Google’s Overview.
Do ChatGPT and Gemini recommend the same eye doctors?
We measured how often two platforms named at least one practice in common for the same question. ChatGPT and Gemini, the two largest platforms, did on 20.1% of questions.
| Platform Pair | Shared at least one practice |
|---|---|
| Claude + Perplexity | 63.0% |
| ChatGPT + Perplexity | 49.6% |
| ChatGPT + Claude | 40.7% |
| Claude + Gemini | 32.1% |
| Gemini + Perplexity | 26.4% |
| ChatGPT + Gemini | 20.1% |
What this means in practice: being named by one platform does not mean the next one names you. Claude answered only 28 questions in this study, so treat its pairs as rough.
Do LensCrafters and Pearle Vision dominate AI results?
National chains like LensCrafters, Pearle Vision, VisionWorks and My EyeLab do not dominate AI answers.
Franchise mentions accounted for 1.6% of all AI mentions. Independent practices got the other 98.4%.
Which directories do AI platforms use to find eye doctors?
We tracked every site AI named across all 483 answers. Two sites lead.
| Site | Answers naming it |
|---|---|
| Healthgrades | 180 |
| Google (any form) | 151 |
| Zocdoc | 134 |
| Yelp | 66 |
| WebMD | 32 |
| Vitals.com | 17 |
| Angi | 3 |
Healthgrades was named in 37% of answers and Zocdoc in 28%. For eye care practices, these are the two listings to get right first. Check that each one is claimed and that your name, address, phone number, and hours match your website.
What should eye care practices do about AI visibility?
Eye care practices should start with the two medical directories AI names most, then check every platform.
- Claim and complete Healthgrades and Zocdoc. Match your name, address, phone and hours to your website.
- Ask patients for reviews that name the visit, such as an eye exam or LASIK consult.
- Find out which platforms name your practice today. Most practices appear on only one.
Three of 1,037 practices were named by every platform we could compare.
The free Local Vitals scan checks your practice across all five AI platforms in about 60 seconds.
What are the limits of this study?
The study covers 10 Florida metros in April 2026, re-counted in November 2026. Claude answered only 28 questions and Google AI Overviews appeared on only 6 searches, so comparisons that involve them are rough. Gemini was tested without live search. The full method is on the study page.
For the rest of the plan (listings, reviews, recall follow-up and how to measure booked exams), see Optometry Marketing: A Practical Guide to Local Growth.
Find out what AI says about your practice.
See Who ChatGPT Recommends