Skip to main content
← All posts
Original ResearchPublished · Updated

We Asked 4 AI Platforms to Recommend a Florida Plumber. 73% of the Plumbers Showed Up on Only One.

When a Florida homeowner asks AI for a plumber, AI names a specific plumbing business in 99.5% of answers, but the four platforms rarely agree on which one: 73% of the 978 plumbers named showed up on only one. That is from the Local Vitals Florida Plumber AI Visibility Study (April 2026, 600 questions across 10 Florida metros), and it is for plumbing owners who want to know whether AI names them.

Sixteen plumbers were named by all four platforms. To run the same kind of test on your own company, see what an AI visibility checker measures for plumbers.

Which AI platforms and Florida cities did we test for plumbers?

We ran the same types of queries a homeowner would type: "best plumber in Tampa," "I need an emergency plumber in Jacksonville," "top rated drain cleaning service near Miami." Five specialties: general plumber, emergency plumber, drain cleaning, water heater repair, and sewer line. Three query variations per specialty, across all 10 metros, on each of the four platforms. That's 600 data points.

For every response, we recorded whether the AI named specific local businesses (an "A-response"), gave generic advice, referred to a directory, or just didn't answer. Then we compared what each platform said.

Does AI actually recommend plumbers by name?

99.5% of the time, AI named specific plumbing businesses (597 of 600 answers). Claude and Gemini did it on every single query. Perplexity missed once out of 150 and ChatGPT twice. The old concern that AI just gives vague advice doesn't hold up for plumbing. When someone asks for a plumber, AI almost always answers with names.

The pattern is spread. 72.8% of the 978 plumbers AI named appeared on just one platform. Sixteen appeared on all four.

Another 160 plumbers appeared on two platforms and 90 on three. The 16 on all four include Roto-Rooter and Mr. Rooter of Tallahassee, and also companies like Wimpy's Plumbing & Air, Frank Gay Services, and Bill The Plumber.

Do the AI platforms recommend the same plumbers?

Platform pairNamed a plumber in common
Claude and Perplexity69.8%
ChatGPT and Claude55.4%
ChatGPT and Perplexity46.9%
Gemini and Claude25.3%
Gemini and ChatGPT19.6%
Gemini and Perplexity18.8%

Claude, ChatGPT and Perplexity searched the web when they answered, and they overlap the most.

Gemini was the outlier. We asked it through its API without a live search, so it answered from training data. It shared a plumber with Claude on 25.3% of questions, with ChatGPT on 19.6%, and with Perplexity on 18.8%.

Does Perplexity name specific plumbers?

Yes. Perplexity named a plumber in 149 of 150 answers. It also pointed to directories: Angi showed up in 86 of its 150 answers, Thumbtack in 32, and the BBB in 27.

How often do Roto-Rooter and Mr. Rooter appear in AI results?

15% of AI plumber mentions were franchise brands and national chains like Roto-Rooter and Mr. Rooter (459 of 3,068). Roto-Rooter was named by all four platforms in all 10 cities.

That said, 85% of mentions still went to independent plumbers. The franchises have an edge, but they don't dominate.

Which directories does AI use to find plumbers in Florida?

These are the sites AI named most when recommending Florida plumbers:

SiteAnswers that named it (of 600)
Angi178
Google, in any form155
Yelp135
BBB79
Thumbtack37
HomeAdvisor33

If you're a plumber, start with Angi. It was named in more answers about Florida plumbers than any other site. Check that your listing is claimed and that your name, address, phone number, and hours match your website.

What should Florida plumbers do about AI visibility?

Three things are clear from this data. First, AI is already recommending plumbers by name in nearly every answer. This is happening now, not in the future. Second, 73% of the plumbers AI named showed up on one platform only, so being named by one tells you little about the other three. Third, the sites AI names most for plumbers are Angi, Yelp, and the BBB, so those are the listings to get right first.

The spread is the opportunity. Only 16 of 978 plumbers were named by all four platforms. Find out which platforms name you, then work on the ones that don't.

What are the limits of this study?

The study covers 10 Florida metros in April 2026 and was re-counted in November 2026. Gemini was asked through its API without live search, AI answers change over time, and Google AI Overviews were not part of the plumber count. The full method is on the study page.

Want to see where your plumbing business stands on AI search? Find out in 60 seconds.

Check Your AI Visibility